New twist on popular reverse mortgage
Question: Allison, what do you know about reverse mortgages? I this just a gimmick?
Answer: Reverse mortgages definitely are on the rise. Senior homeowners are taking equity out of their longtime residences to make ends meet during their retirement years, and to remodel their homes and help their children and grandchildren with the financial challenges of higher education.
In fact, the Home Equity Conversion Mortgage, which is insured by the federal government and is the nation's most popular reverse mortgage, jumped from 43,081 closings in fiscal-year 2005 to 76,276 in fiscal 2006.
As reverse-mortgage funds are spent and the interest on these mortgages accrues, the lender gains a greater piece of the home. But let's consider another possibility. What if a family member or a close friend received that equity instead of the lender?
Circle Lending, an aptly named, Waltham, Mass.-based company specializing in the organization of family and small-business loans, has introduced Family Advantage, a sort of reverse mortgage that keeps the home in the family -- or with a friend or associate -- once the senior homeowner moves out or dies.
"It's not for everybody, but it has filled a niche, especially for some adult children who are already supporting their parents," said Jim Smith, vice president of marketing and sales for Circle Lending. "It puts the arrangement into a business deal where all family members can see that it's all documented and very clear."
Conventional reverse mortgages allow senior homeowners, with a minimum age of 62, to receive proceeds from a lender -- either in a lump sum, regular monthly payments, a line of credit or in a combination of those options. When the house is sold, or the last remaining borrower dies or moves out of the home, the loan amount plus the accrued interest is repaid. The borrower can't owe more than the value of the home. The HECM program has insured more than 240,000 reverse mortgages since 1990, while private "jumbo" reverse plans also have been available.
The Family Advantage concept requires a family member or friend to write a check every month -- or make a lump-sum payment -- to the parent or homeowner. In return, the person writing the check earns an equity interest in the home, plus interest, when the homeowner moves out. It's basically a home-equity loan funded by a family member or friend, secured by real estate. Hence, payments are received tax-free.
The challenge is locating a family member or friend with the means to play the bank. According to Circle Lending, the average rate negotiated between the two participating parties has been about 6 percent because the lending (related) party is not looking to maximize the return.
"A lot of times, at least one of the kids is already supporting the parents with some sort of monthly income," Smith said. "But none of these payments are documented, or other siblings have no idea that one of their brothers or sisters is even helping the folks at all. Family Advantage documents all of these payments and creates a lien on the home that is repaid before other family members receive their interest in the home -- which makes up a great deal of the average person's estate."
The cost to set up the Family Advantage loan averages $2,499 (includes documentation, lien recording, ongoing service, upfront consultation and distribution of the repayment) plus $9 for each payment made, typically a monthly check to the folks. However, lump-sum payments can be substituted at any time, allowing the lender-child to earmark expected bonuses to the program or other funds that could be coming from stock sales, home sales or potential big-ticket windfalls.
"We have one client who is a widow with no children," Smith said. "She owns her home and contacted an acquaintance -- somebody who has significant assets. They are obviously unrelated but they worked out an arrangement where the acquaintance will slowly accumulate equity in the property by making monthly payments to the homeowner. They worked out an acceptable interest rate for both sides."
The upside of the concept is that there is no age restriction; the property secured could be a principal residence, second home or investment property; and the upfront closing costs are less than the standard reverse mortgage. In addition, borrower and lender are free to negotiate a reasonable interest rate yet one that clearly reflects a genuine business deal.
The downside of the deal is that the homeowners have no immediate recourse if the payments cease.
"We were simply looking for a way for people to annuitize their home and have the relinquished equity go to somebody they knew," Smith said. "We provide a professional, third party to oversee the deal. We've found it's simply a vehicle some families and friends can use."
For answers to your real estate questions, call Allison at 970-468-6800 or 1-800-262-8442